The short answer: keep one record per policy (insurer, policy number, amount, beneficiaries, who to call) in one place your family can reach, and make sure at least one person knows it exists. A folder, a spreadsheet, a digital vault or a service built for life insurance can all do it. What matters is that the record is complete and that someone will find it.
What to record for each policy
- Insurance company and its claims phone number
- Policy number and type (term, whole, universal, group through work)
- Death benefit amount
- Beneficiaries, and the date you last checked them
- Premium amount, how it is paid and from which account
- Agent, broker or HR contact
- Where the paper policy is kept
Policies families most often miss: group life insurance through an employer (including a former one), coverage tied to a mortgage or a bank account, accidental-death coverage from a credit card, union or association plans, and old paid-up policies from decades ago. Add them even if the amount seems small.
The options, compared
| Option | What it is | A good fit if… | Price* |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paper folder | One labeled folder with copies of every policy and the list above. | Your family lives nearby and everyone knows where the folder is. | Free |
| Spreadsheet + password manager | A shared sheet with the list, stored in a cloud drive or a family password manager such as 1Password Families. | You are comfortable keeping it up to date yourself. | Free to low cost |
| Everplans | A digital planning vault for wills, directives, accounts and insurance, with "deputies" who can access what you choose. | You want a full end-of-life plan, not only insurance. | Free for 3 items; Premium $99.99/year |
| Trustworthy | A family vault for IDs, legal, financial and insurance documents, with reminders and sharing. | You want the whole household's paperwork in one app. | Free plan; paid plans from $10/month billed annually |
| Quicken LifeHub | An app from Quicken to organize, protect and share essential information, with "after I'm gone" access for trusted contacts. | You already like Quicken or want household records with roles. | Subscription; see quicken.com |
| AARP Digital Vault (by Prisidio) | A secure vault add-on for AARP members to store and share important records. | You or your parent is an AARP member. | $20/year add-on to membership |
| Afterglow | A service only for life insurance: we keep your policies and the people you named ready, and on the day your family uploads the death certificate, we notify the insurers and prepare each claim for them to sign. In pilot. | You want your family to have one place to go, and help with the claims, not just a copy of the papers. | Free during the beta; then $5/month, with a lifetime discount for Early Birds |
*Prices as shown on each company's website on November 9, 2026. They can change; check before you sign up. Names are trademarks of their owners. Afterglow has no relationship with these companies.
How to choose
- Who will open it? Pick the option the person who will need it can actually use. A vault no one has the login to helps no one.
- Is it only insurance, or everything? A general vault holds every document. A life-insurance service goes deeper on one thing: the claim.
- Will it stay current? Set one yearly reminder, for example on a birthday, to check beneficiaries and add any new policy.
If you don't know what policies exist
None of these tools can list a policy nobody wrote down. After a death, families can use the free NAIC Life Insurance Policy Locator, the MIB Policy Locator Service, and state unclaimed-property searches such as unclaimed.org and MissingMoney.com. Our guide to lost life insurance explains each one.
Common questions
Is there an app just for life insurance policies?
Most apps are general vaults that also hold insurance. Afterglow is built only for life insurance and for the claim on the day it matters; it is in pilot, with an Early Bird list open.
Can my insurance agent add my policies?
With Afterglow, yes: your agent can send your policies for you, and each agent sees only the policies linked to them. In general vaults, you usually upload documents yourself.
Should my beneficiaries know about the policy now?
It is your choice. Many families tell at least one person that a policy exists and where the record is, so it is never a surprise.